On the Way SP Convenience

Directions

On the Way SP Convenience Convenience Store Open 7 days a week 8:30-9
Ice Cream / Deli Open 7 days a week 10-8
Can Redemption Open 7 days a week 9-6
No Large Loads After 5!

Please Keep in Mind with the Cold
Our Employees May Leave Early so Call Ahead!

Our Cans Are OPEN 7 Days a Week 9 - 6CANS MAY CLOSE EARLIER THAN 6!if it's been slow so if you're coming after 4:30/5 pl...
11/03/2026

Our Cans Are OPEN 7 Days a Week 9 - 6

CANS MAY CLOSE EARLIER THAN 6!
if it's been slow so if you're coming after 4:30/5
please call ahead to let us know so we have the staff.

Posting Some of Our Rules *
I know the Carbliss, Surf Side, etc. is confusing because they do have a $.05 on top but the company who takes our cans will not accept them (pay us)
and in our Liquor Store you are not charged the deposit.
As far as no more pre-counts we have been taken advantage of too many times. We pay for cans just to open the bags and find non-returnables, garbage, etc.
Sad but true.
One of the biggest rules is to please have
ALL GLASS SEPARATE from cans! If we open your bags to throw on the conveyor belt to be put through the can counting machine and there is glass in the bags usually what happens is the glass will shatter and can get caught in the machine. It's happened before and was not a cheap fix!!! We will provide boxes for you to separate your glass if needed.

Thank You to All Our Customers 🙂

It's unfortunate that some children wake up to very little or nothing at all Christmas morning...But YOU COULD CHANGE th...
11/03/2026

It's unfortunate that some children wake up to very little or nothing at all Christmas morning...
But YOU COULD CHANGE that!!!
Make a child smile this holiday season by stopping in and grabbing a tag.
All gifts must be returned by December 7th
Thank you 🎁

Some of the Trick or Treaters Thank you to everyone who stopped in 🍦
11/02/2026

Some of the Trick or Treaters
Thank you to everyone who stopped in 🍦

This Weeks Menu Potato, Pasta & Chicken SaladLoaded Baked Potato SoupGoulashBBQ Beef BrisketPork Chop, Stuffing & Veggie...
10/30/2026

This Weeks Menu

Potato, Pasta & Chicken Salad
Loaded Baked Potato Soup
Goulash
BBQ Beef Brisket
Pork Chop, Stuffing & Veggie Dinner
Garlic Chicken, Stuffing & Veggie Dinner
Acorn Squash with Corn Bread Stuffing

🎗️🎗️🎗️
10/28/2026

🎗️🎗️🎗️

Looking for Something Extra for your Costume?Try Colored Contacts to Complete your Look
10/27/2026

Looking for Something Extra for your Costume?

Try Colored Contacts to Complete your Look

Our Rough Draft of Our NEW Sub Menu 🥪You Can Call Ahead (607)735-2900   & Pick Up through the Ice Cream Drive Thru!     ...
10/26/2026

Our Rough Draft of Our NEW Sub Menu 🥪

You Can Call Ahead (607)735-2900
& Pick Up through the Ice Cream Drive Thru!
ONLY PRE-ORDERS THROUGH DRIVE THRU

We also have these additional toppings & dressings
* Jalapeno Peppers
* Sweet Peppers
* Obviously Mayo, Mustard, Oil & Vinegar
* Ranch, Italian Dressing
* Wraps also available - Ask for flavors

Any Suggestions? Let Us Know...
We Are Always Open to New Ideas

New Page and I Still Forgot to Post Friday 🤦...  Anyways This Weeks Heat & Eat isPotato, Mac, Dill Pickle & Tossed Salad...
10/26/2026

New Page and I Still Forgot to Post Friday 🤦... Anyways This Weeks Heat & Eat is

Potato, Mac, Dill Pickle & Tossed Salad
The Dill Pickle Salad is Soooo yummy!
Pulled BBQ Pork
Ham & Bean Soup
Sausage Peppers & Onions
Blackened Chicken BBQ with Mac Salad Dinner
Grilled Chicken with Mac & Cheese Dinner
Hot Dogs & Sauerkraut with Mac & Cheese Dinner
Texas Meat Sauce
Mac & Cheese
Chicken Fingers
Buffalo Chicken Wrap

Weekend Special - Meatball Sub Half $4.99    Whole $8.99Not in the Mood for Meatballs???We Now Make Subs...  Italian wit...
10/23/2026

Weekend Special - Meatball Sub
Half $4.99 Whole $8.99
Not in the Mood for Meatballs???
We Now Make Subs... Italian with Capicola,
Ham, Turkey, Tuna, Chicken Salad
Deli is OPEN 7 days a week 10-8
If You Call Ahead (607) 735-2900 ☎️
You Can Pick Up Through Ice Cream Drive Thru!
But ONLY Pre-orders Through Drive Thru So
We Don't Hold Up the Ice Cream Customers

Address

1825B Pennsylvania Avenue
Pine City, NY
14871

Opening Hours

Monday 8:30am - 9pm
Tuesday 8:30am - 9pm
Wednesday 8:30am - 9pm
Thursday 8:30am - 9pm
Friday 8:30am - 9pm
Saturday 8:30am - 9pm
Sunday 8:30am - 9pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when On the Way SP Convenience posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Nearby convenience stores