Bayside Grocery

Call Directions

Bayside Grocery You will find fresh made subs, pizza, groceries, hardware and everything in between, at Bayside! Forget your hammer for that weekend DIY project?

The moment you walk into Bayside Grocery, you’ll realize it isn’t just your average local market. From deli-fresh subs to quality fuel for your car, we are truly are Fair Haven’s one-stop shop. Having grown up shopping at Bayside themselves, the owners are attuned to their customers’ every want and need. Don’t worry -- we’ve got one. How about a fresh doughnut to start off your morning or a delicious slice of pizza to curb that lunchtime craving? It’s all waiting for you here. We’re more than just a convenient store, we’re a full-service store that’s here for your convenience.

10/06/2026

Tuesday October 6th
Lunch special 😋
Lasagna and a breadstick $9.99

10/05/2026

Lunch special for Monday October 5th
School lunch:
Turkey, gravy and mashed potatoes over bread 😋
Soup: Cheesey Sausage Potato

Tuesday Night Dinner October 6thSlow Roasted Black Forest pork chop served with roasted potatoes and homemade applesauce...
10/01/2026

Tuesday Night Dinner
October 6th
Slow Roasted Black Forest pork chop served with roasted potatoes and homemade applesauce 🍎 We start serving at 4pm
(Doug from the Cottage Inn's) Recipe😉

10/01/2026

Its Pizza Thursday here today..... 🍕
Large 18" Cheese Pizza $10.99
($2.00 additional toppings)

10/01/2026

Next Tuesday October 6th
We will be kicking off our Tuesday Night Dinners.
We have a treat for you. I Wendy Alice reached out to a really great friend, ex boss and an incredible chef for his Black Forrest Pork recipe. 😋
Straight from Doug the owner Of Cottage Inn,
I will attempt to recreate one of his all time favorites 😍

Lunch special for Wednesday September 30th Chicken gravy over mashed potatoes 😋
09/30/2026

Lunch special for Wednesday September 30th
Chicken gravy over mashed potatoes 😋

Lunch special for Tuesday September 29thPulled pork sandwich, coleslaw with Mac and cheese $8.99
09/29/2026

Lunch special for Tuesday September 29th
Pulled pork sandwich, coleslaw with Mac and cheese $8.99

Fast easy and delicious 😋 Chicken Philly Chicken, peppers, onion ( no mushrooms) All ingredients can be purchased at Bay...
09/28/2026

Fast easy and delicious 😋
Chicken Philly
Chicken, peppers, onion
( no mushrooms)
All ingredients can be purchased at Bayside Grocery in Fair Haven
Made by Wendy Alice at home ❤️

Happy Monday 😊 Lunch special for September 28thLarge Stuffed Pepper with a breadstick $8.99Chili is available 😋
09/28/2026

Happy Monday 😊
Lunch special for September 28th
Large Stuffed Pepper with a breadstick $8.99

Chili is available 😋

Address

537 Main Street
Fair Haven, NY
13064

Opening Hours

Monday 6am - 7pm
Tuesday 6am - 7pm
Wednesday 6am - 7pm
Thursday 6am - 7pm
Friday 6am - 8pm
Saturday 6am - 8pm
Sunday 6am - 7pm

Telephone

+13159475708

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Bayside Grocery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category